Tuesday, 18 April 2017

IIFYM VS "CLEAN EATING"

Clean eating follows the misconception that there are “good foods” and “bad foods”. Clean eating may be described as a “stricter” way of eating as there are many foods that you must avoid, there are also many more rules in terms of food organisation, for example, eating every three hours and no carbs after dark. There are many misconceptions about “clean eating” these include, eating “clean” foods will help you gain muscle/ lose fat faster, you can’t gain fat from eating “clean” foods, you will stay a lot leaner while you are in a surplus if you eat clean foods, you don’t need to worry about calories if you are eating clean, you won’t lose fat even if you are in deficit calories if they contain “dirty” foods, eating 6 small meals a day is better, not eating carbs at night will prevent you from gaining fat and that the calories from a certain food will make you fatter than calories from another food. From my point of view, none of this is true.

In terms of diet, changes in body happen as a result of your total calorie intake not the specific foods you are eating.
The problem with clean eating is that many people find it a lot harder to stay consistent as it does not allow flexibility in terms of eating out with others, eating certain foods at certain times and allowing yourself to eat foods that you are craving.
Although there are negatives about clean eating there are also some positives, including the fact that it encourages people to eat foods with a better micronutrient profile than other foods. There are also some people that find it easier to stick to clean eating as it is a more structured way of eating.

“If it fits your macros” refers to the protein, fat and carbs that you are consuming. With iifym there are no foods that have to be avoided and no strictness in structure that must be followed. As long as you reach your calories, protein, fat, carb and fibre intake for the day you can eat whatever you like, whenever you like. A lot of people seem to think that people who follow iifym only eat poptarts and frozen yoghurt, however, majority of people follow a 90/10 or 80/20 principle (80-90% whole food and the remainder of calories made up of flexible foods). Therefore, iifym is very similar to clean eating however, allows for a lot more variety and flexibility. There are a few problems with iifym, these are that some people find that it is too flexible and they need an exact meal plan to follow, and the other reason is that there are some people that fill majority of their calories with foods with very little nutritional benefits, making them feel sluggish and causing skin problems. The good things about iifym are that you are able to eat in a way that suits you, as there is so much freedom and flexibility, you can eat foods that you enjoy, eat out at social events and eat without a schedule.

The way that I use iifym is I plan out my day in advanced, I make sure to hit my fibre (I do about 15g per 1000 calories) and protein (at the moment I am doing 1.2g per pound of bodyweight) intake for the day then I fill the rest of the day with my fats and carbs, always making sure that I have enough room for foods that I love each night for when I come home from a long day of work.


Personally, I think neither one is superior, I think that it is completely up to personal preference, whatever one you think that you will be able to stick to as you want to make it a lifestyle, not just a diet with an end date. This is because both of them have a calorie goal, with a macro and micro nutrient breakdown, it’s just a matter what foods you are going to eat to reach your calorie, carb, fat, protein and fibre targets. 

No comments:

Post a Comment